Fantasy Hockey – Consensus Top 300 Ranking

Sep 5, 2025, 13:45 EDTUpdated: Sep 5, 2025, 13:53 EDT

Fantasy Hockey – Consensus Top 300 Ranking

Our team of Fantasy Hockey analysts have each compiled their own Top 250 or Top 300 rankings for the 2025-26 NHL season. Each individual list can be found below, but these rankings combine all five lists into a consensus Top 300.

Each analyst’s rankings are based on similar scoring settings, primarily using G, A, PPP, SOG for Skaters while also factoring “banger” categories such as hits and other stats like plus-minus (despite some of its real-life flaws). For Goalies, we used Wins, GAA, SV%, and SO.

The consensus rankings are created by averaging out each analyst’s ranking, but also factoring in how many analysts have that player in their top 250 (ECR%).

We will also be releasing an ECR vs. ADP comparison tool, so you can easily see which players we are higher or lower than ADP on each platform.

Individual Rankings:

Rank	Player	Team	Pos.	Avg	Brock	Beebs	Dylan	Matt	Nick
1	Connor McDavid	EDM	C	1.6	1	2	1	3	1
2	Nathan MacKinnon	COL	C	1.8	2	1	3	1	2
3	Nikita Kucherov	TBL	RW	3.0	3	3	2	4	3
4	Leon Draisaitl	EDM	C,LW	3.6	4	4	4	2	4
5	David Pastrnak	BOS	RW	5.8	6	6	5	6	5
6	Cale Makar	COL	D	7.0	8	5	7	5	10
7	Kirill Kaprizov	MIN	LW	7.4	7	7	10	7	7
8	Connor Hellebuyck	WPG	G	7.6	5	8	9	8	8
9	Auston Matthews	TOR	C	8.0	9	9	6	10	6
10	Mikko Rantanen	DAL	LW,RW	11.4	12	11	11	9	11
11	Brady Tkachuk	OTT	C,LW	11.6	16	10	8	15	9
12	Kyle Connor	WPG	LW	13.6	14	12	14	11	18
13	William Nylander	TOR	C,RW	14.6	13	18	12	19	12
14	Artemi Panarin	NYR	LW	15.2	10	16	13	22	15
15	Jack Eichel	VGK	C	15.6	18	14	21	12	13
16	Jack Hughes	NJD	C,LW	16.6	19	21	15	14	14
17	Quinn Hughes	VAN	D	17.2	11	17	16	16	26
18	Mitch Marner	VGK	RW	18.4	24	13	22	13	20
19	Andrei Vasilevskiy	TBL	G	18.4	15	19	17	21	21
20	Brayden Point	TBL	C	22.0	17	15	19	26	33
21	Evan Bouchard	EDM	D	24.0	20	23	29	17	31
22	Tage Thompson	BUF	C,RW	24.6	29	24	24	20	24
23	Sam Reinhart	FLA	C,RW	25.0	27	28	18	27	23
24	Jason Robertson	DAL	LW,RW	27.2	28	31	26	29	22
25	Sidney Crosby	PIT	C	27.8	35	26	23	38	17
26	Zach Werenski	CBJ	D	28.0	21	20	37	24	38
27	Filip Forsberg	NSH	LW	28.6	26	30	34	37	16
28	Jake Guentzel	TBL	LW	29.2	31	29	25	35	27
29	Jake Oettinger	DAL	G	30.2	22	37	27	25	40
30	Clayton Keller	UTA	LW,RW	30.6	34	25	31	28	35
31	Jesper Bratt	NJD	LW,RW	32.4	36	34	30	30	32
32	Martin Necas	COL	RW	34.2	44	22	38	47	19
33	Tim Stützle	OTT	C,LW	35.4	47	42	35	23	29
34	Igor Shesterkin	NYR	G	35.6	33	33	32	45	36
35	Sergei Bobrovsky	FLA	G	36.8	23	44	44	32	41
36	Rasmus Dahlin	BUF	D	37.4	32	36	53	18	49
37	Matt Boldy	MIN	LW,RW	37.8	30	45	33	54	28
38	Brandon Hagel	TBL	LW,RW	38.0	56	27	28	34	46
39	J.T. Miller	NYR	C,RW	39.0	48	55	20	46	25
40	Mackenzie Blackwood	COL	G	39.0	25	32	41	60	37
41	Sebastian Aho	CAR	C	39.6	42	47	36	39	34
42	Adrian Kempe	LAK	RW	42.0	49	46	42	41	30
43	Mark Scheifele	WPG	C	42.0	43	35	39	43	50
44	Nick Suzuki	MTL	C	45.0	51	41	45	33	56
45	Cole Caufield	MTL	LW,RW	47.4	50	40	40	57	43
46	Adam Fox	NYR	D	49.6	38	50	46	49	66
47	Alex Ovechkin	WSH	LW,RW	49.8	45	49	74	42	42
48	Wyatt Johnston	DAL	C,RW	50.6	55	51	47	53	47
49	Matvei Michkov	PHI	RW	51.0	57	39	48	56	54
50	Macklin Celebrini	SJS	C	51.8	52	38	51	51	64
51	Aleksander Barkov	FLA	C	52.4	59	63	55	48	44
52	Lucas Raymond	DET	RW	54.2	61	43	61	36	71
53	Victor Hedman	TBL	D	54.8	40	48	68	40	78
54	Josh Morrissey	WPG	D	57.4	41	52	57	52	85
55	Lane Hutson	MTL	D	59.0	60	56	56	31	93
56	Dylan Larkin	DET	C	59.8	54	64	52	77	53
57	Roman Josi	NSH	D	60.4	37	73	49	81	62
58	Travis Konecny	PHI	LW,RW	61.2	91	69	43	50	52
59	Darcy Kuemper	LAK	G	61.2	67	53	75	66	45
60	John Tavares	TOR	C	62.0	64	65	59	79	39
61	Dylan Guenther	UTA	RW	62.8	53	76	50	83	51
62	Seth Jarvis	CAR	C,LW,RW	63.4	71	70	67	58	48
63	Alex DeBrincat	DET	LW,RW	65.2	58	57	72	65	67
64	Connor Bedard	CHI	C,RW	65.2	75	59	58	44	90
65	Kevin Fiala	LAK	LW	66.8	39	62	71	99	63
66	Nico Hischier	NJD	C	69.0	69	74	60	73	74
67	Robert Thomas	STL	C	70.0	79	61	70	69	73
68	Jordan Kyrou	STL	RW	72.2	70	81	64	67	76
69	Mika Zibanejad	NYR	C,RW	72.4	63	54	80	97	68
70	Filip Gustavsson	MIN	G	74.2	68	75	76	93	59
71	Adin Hill	VGK	G	74.6	82	72	84	72	65
72	Roope Hintz	DAL	C	75.4	76	83	62	71	84
73	Matthew Knies	TOR	LW	76.6	90	82	89	59	58
74	Elias Pettersson	VAN	C,LW	78.2	80	58	54	107	81
75	Kirill Marchenko	CBJ	RW	78.4	98	86	65	63	77
76	Nazem Kadri	CGY	C	78.8	74	68	100	96	57
77	Shea Theodore	VGK	D	79.8	46	67	66	106	113
78	Dustin Wolf	CGY	G	83.0	83	88	99	55	92
79	Ilya Sorokin	NYI	G	83.0	96	100	78	74	70
80	JJ Peterka	UTA	LW,RW	84.6	92	66	86	76	106
81	Nikolaj Ehlers	CAR	LW,RW	86.8	72	99	81	78	102
82	Andrei Svechnikov	CAR	LW,RW	87.0	99	125	63	70	79
83	Carter Verhaeghe	FLA	LW	87.2	85	117	79	95	61
84	Mackenzie Weegar	CGY	D	88.8	78	80	97	82	107
85	Anthony Stolarz	TOR	G	90.8	97	92	93	87	86
86	Logan Thompson	WSH	G	91.0	95	84	96	64	118
87	Zach Hyman	EDM	LW,RW	91.4	94	127	69	115	55
88	Dougie Hamilton	NJD	D	92.4	66	78	87	114	117
89	Alex Tuch	BUF	RW	92.8	122	90	106	62	83
90	Valeri Nichushkin	COL	LW,RW	96.4	100	60	90	113	120
91	Linus Ullmark	OTT	G	97.4	106	94	105	68	114
92	Pavel Dorofeyev	VGK	LW,RW	97.8	62	96	122	127	82
93	Jake Sanderson	OTT	D	98.4	65	77	117	85	148
94	Adam Fantilli	CBJ	C	99.4	105	91	92	61	144
95	Jacob Markstrom	NJD	G	99.8	110	89	103	84	111
96	Tom Wilson	WSH	RW	99.8	137	87	95	105	75
97	Vincent Trocheck	NYR	C	100.2	118	119	101	75	87
98	Drake Batherson	OTT	LW,RW	100.2	101	85	114	98	103
99	Stuart Skinner	EDM	G	101.0	89	97	107	122	91
100	Dylan Holloway	STL	C,LW	102.0	121	98	149	80	69
101	Juuse Saros	NSH	G	103.2	88	105	109	155	60
102	Juraj Slafkovsky	MTL	LW,RW	103.6	93	101	104	116	108
103	Logan Cooley	UTA	C	103.8	112	71	120	88	136
104	Dylan Strome	WSH	C	104.6	123	95	77	100	133
105	Matthew Tkachuk	FLA	LW,RW	106.4	77	140	85	131	97
106	Joel Eriksson Ek	MIN	C	107.2	117	103	124	119	72
107	Timo Meier	NJD	LW,RW	107.8	111	109	144	94	80
108	Quinton Byfield	LAK	C,LW	107.8	116	93	108	126	96
109	Bo Horvat	NYI	C	109.2	104	121	121	111	89
110	Mathew Barzal	NYI	C,RW	111.0	160	131	73	91	100
111	Jordan Binnington	STL	G	113.6	113	114	118	118	105
112	Sam Montembeault	MTL	G	117.4	130	110	151	108	88
113	Jared McCann	SEA	C,LW	119.6	142	104	116	137	99
114	Thomas Harley	DAL	D	121.4	73	111	172	103	145
115	Matt Duchene	DAL	C,RW	122.8	154	156	82	101	122
116	Mikhail Sergachev	UTA	D	123.0	81	124	125	109	177
117	Miro Heiskanen	DAL	D	123.4	87	150	91	117	173
118	Moritz Seider	DET	D	124.8	84	164	160	92	126
119	Rickard Rakell	PIT	C,LW,RW	125.2	132	113	154	132	95
120	Mark Stone	VGK	RW	129.6	155	141	83	89	180
121	Gabriel Vilardi	WPG	C,RW	129.6	129	79	142	152	146
122	Bryan Rust	PIT	RW	130.0	133	144	130	134	109
123	Owen Tippett	PHI	LW,RW	131.0	178	137	94	130	116
124	Ryan Nugent-Hopkins	EDM	C,LW	131.0	144	165	88	143	115
125	Pyotr Kochetkov	CAR	G	131.4	120	116	115	178	127
126	Frederik Andersen	CAR	G	132.4	119	133	146	138	125
127	Karel Vejmelka	UTA	G	132.4	131	123	139	139	130
128	Steven Stamkos	NSH	C,LW,RW	133.8	124	148	112	164	121
129	Tomas Hertl	VGK	C,LW	134.0	147	151	102	120	150
130	Ivan Demidov	MTL	RW	138.0	169	112	111	102	196
131	Jeremy Swayman	BOS	G	138.0	174	128	110	159	119
132	Thatcher Demko	VAN	G	139.0	146	129	129	151	140
133	Jonathan Marchessault	NSH	RW	141.2	141	146	176	149	94
134	Joey Daccord	SEA	G	142.0	175	130	126	150	129
135	Jakob Chychrun	WSH	D	142.2	103	159	164	133	152
136	Tyler Toffoli	SJS	LW,RW	142.2	156	157	119	156	123
137	Sam Bennett	FLA	C	143.4	167	162	166	124	98
138	Noah Dobson	MTL	D	143.6	102	183	157	110	166
139	John Carlson	WSH	D	143.8	108	176	132	125	178
140	Pavel Buchnevich	STL	C,LW,RW	145.0	173	139	127	145	141
141	Brock Boeser	VAN	RW	145.2	143	170	134	144	135
142	Will Smith	SJS	C,RW	145.6	184	102	98	147	197
143	Brock Nelson	COL	C	146.0	158	149	128	158	137
144	Leo Carlsson	ANA	C	148.8	161	115	189	86	193
145	Patrick Kane	DET	RW	149.0	152	145	152	184	112
146	Jackson Lacombe	ANA	D	149.4	127	118	167	146	189
147	Jonathan Huberdeau	CGY	C,LW	149.8	153	132	136	181	147
148	Sean Monahan	CBJ	C	150.2	157	136	113	213	132
149	Will Cuylle	NYR	LW,RW	150.6	138	152	197	165	101
150	Lukas Dostal	ANA	G	150.8	176	166	148	90	174
151	Brad Marchand	FLA	LW	151.4	159	175	145	136	142
152	Nick Schmaltz	UTA	C,RW	152.4	183	106	138	160	175
153	Alexis Lafrenière	NYR	LW,RW	153.8	177	155	147	141	149
154	Marco Kasper	DET	C,LW	154.8	163	169	141	167	134
155	Dylan Cozens	OTT	C	155.0	162	153	190	166	104
156	Chris Kreider	ANA	LW	155.4	172	163	161	171	110
157	Kent Johnson	CBJ	C,LW,RW	156.4	182	122	140	128	210
158	John Gibson	DET	G	157.4	190	126	174	121	176
159	Joseph Woll	TOR	G	157.4	197	158	135	154	143
160	Morgan Geekie	BOS	C,LW,RW	157.8	168	120	163	180	158
161	Evgeni Malkin	PIT	C,LW	157.8	164	167	133	187	138
162	Luke Hughes	NJD	D	158.4	114	191	201	104	182
163	Mason McTavish	ANA	C	158.6	181	134	192	135	151
164	Marco Rossi	MIN	C	159.6	186	108	187	157	160
165	Shayne Gostisbehere	CAR	D	159.8	109	187	159	172	172
166	Artturi Lehkonen	COL	LW,RW	160.2	188	154	158	148	153
167	Charlie McAvoy	BOS	D	162.4	115	223	150	129	195
168	Erik Karlsson	PIT	D	164.0	107	232	137	142	202
169	Pierre-Luc Dubois	WSH	C,LW	165.2	180	173	156	162	155
170	Cutter Gauthier	ANA	LW	165.4	179	147	209	123	169
171	Seth Jones	FLA	D	166.4	128	177	168	235	124
172	Vince Dunn	SEA	D	168.4	126	160	162	182	212
173	Anze Kopitar	LAK	C	171.0	229	174	155	112	185
174	Matt Coronato	CGY	RW	171.0	196	107	185	169	198
175	Ryan Donato	CHI	C,LW,RW	171.8	171	135	184	215	154
176	Brandon Montour	SEA	D	173.4	86	192	208	177	205
177	William Eklund	SJS	LW	176.6	192	143	171	153	224
178	Devon Toews	COL	D	178.2	135	211	196	168	181
179	Gabriel Landeskog	COL	LW	178.8	193	161	180	232	128
180	Morgan Rielly	TOR	D	181.0	134	205	173	210	183
181	Josh Norris	BUF	C	182.2	185	138	229	140	219
182	Logan Stankoven	CAR	C,RW	182.6	203	171	204	196	139
183	Troy Terry	ANA	RW	184.8	194	172	170	226	162
184	Claude Giroux	OTT	LW,RW	188.0	210	217	143	191	179
185	Drew Doughty	LAK	D	189.0	125	225	179	173	243
186	Connor McMichael	WSH	LW	189.4	216	181	131	220	199
187	Tyler Seguin	DAL	C,RW	189.6	239	184	153	216	156
188	Aliaksei Protas	WSH	LW,RW	190.8	248	189	123	161	233
189	Dmitri Voronkov	CBJ	LW	192.6	211	168	165	254	165
190	Jackson Blake	CAR	RW	197.0	195	199	195	208	188
191	Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen	BUF	G	197.4	217	188	175	203	204
192	Jake DeBrusk	VAN	LW,RW	198.2	208	201	177	221	184
193	Kiefer Sherwood	VAN	RW	199.4	235	209	186	176	191
194	Elias Lindholm	BOS	C	200.0	214	210	216	190	170
195	Aaron Ekblad	FLA	D	200.4	150	214	235	183	220
196	Brayden Schenn	STL	C	201.4	243	195	212	198	159
197	Conor Garland	VAN	RW	201.8	209	185	193	261	161
198	Ivan Barbashev	VGK	LW	203.0	246	197	239	170	163
199	Jimmy Snuggerud	STL	RW	207.4	226	142	203	194
200	Gustav Forsling	FLA	D	209.0	151	206	232	186
201	Brock Faber	MIN	D	211.0	212	198	182	192
202	Anthony Cirelli	TBL	C	211.4	247	226	169	188	207
203	Frank Vatrano	ANA	C,LW	191.3	207		211	185	186
204	Cole Perfetti	WPG	C,LW,RW	213.4	231	220	217	163	214
205	Thomas Chabot	OTT	D	193.8	136	219		202	237
206	Noah Hanifin	VGK	D	215.4	187	213	246	209	200
207	Jeff Skinner	SJS	LW	216.8	220	180	242		164
208	Andrei Kuzmenko	LAK	LW,RW	217.0	206	190	220	207	234
209	Tony DeAngelo	NYI	D	196.0	205	179	202	260	221
210	Mats Zuccarello	MIN	RW	197.3	170	229		174
211	Mason Marchment	SEA	LW	218.6		208	222	225	171
212	Zayne Parekh	CGY	D	198.5	140	242		193
213	Jamie Benn	DAL	C,LW	219.8	244	222	191	228	192
214	Cam Fowler	STL	D	201.5	145		223	214
215	Anders Lee	NYI	LW	224.0	234	204	210	249	187
216	Pavel Zacha	BOS	C,LW	224.6	255	236	194	189	211
217	Evander Kane	VAN	LW	206.5	240	194		276	131
218	Matty Beniers	SEA	C	227.4	230	182	215	263	203
219	Zeev Buium	MIN	D	210.3	149	237		205
220	Spencer Knight	CHI	G	211.5	219	233		200	194
221	Isaac Howard	EDM	LW	212.3	189	196	199	267	248
222	Frank Nazar	CHI	C	215.5	225	200	207	217
223	Sam Rinzel	CHI	D	216.0	139			224	236
224	Jet Greaves	CBJ	G	191.0	191	216		242	213
225	Trevor Zegras	PHI	C	191.7	265	186		175	238
226	Rasmus Andersson	CGY	D	220.5	222	212		179
227	Matias Maccelli	TOR	LW	194.0	202	240	206	243	229
228	Shane Wright	SEA	C	197.0	199	215	243	219	247
229	Warren Foegele	LAK	LW,RW	224.0		207			168
230	Darnell Nurse	EDM	D	224.5	200			201	226
231	Michael Bunting	NSH	LW	224.8	221	221	250		190
232	Jason Zucker	BUF	LW	199.7	241	202	237	290	167
233	Patrik Laine	MTL	LW,RW	225.5	232	247	178	244	245
234	Ryan Leonard	WSH	RW	225.8	242	227	198	229
235	Ryan O’Reilly	NSH	C	243.0	228		219	223	228
236	Alexander Nikishin	CAR	D	204.3	148
237	Boone Jenner	CBJ	C,LW	228.8	215			218	218
238	Mackie Samoskevich	FLA	RW	229.8	218	241	181	262
239	Jiri Kulich	BUF	C	209.0	227	218	228	230
240	Anton Lundell	FLA	C	232.5		235		204	216
241	Neal Pionk	WPG	D	235.8	165			245
242	Blake Coleman	CGY	C,LW,RW	217.0	238		245	275	157
243	Jake Neighbours	STL	LW,RW	218.3	260		230	197	232
244	Mikael Granlund	ANA	C,LW,RW	245.5	263		236	222	209
245	Bobby Brink	PHI	RW	232.0		178
246	Alex Laferriere	LAK	RW	252.0		203		227
247	Oliver Bjorkstrand	TBL	RW	236.7	261	230	240		201
248	Filip Hronek	VAN	D	205.0	198			241
249	Charlie Lindgren	WSH	G	241.7	271		183	248	241
250	Samuel Ersson	PHI	G	215.0	233				208
251	Simon Holmstrom	NYI	RW	245.0		193
252	Matthew Schaefer	NYI	D	246.0	266	224		206
253	Teuvo Teravainen	CHI	LW,RW	219.5			234	212
254	Bowen Byram	BUF	D	220.5	252			195
255	Michael Misa	SJS	C	223.0				199
256	Kris Letang	PIT	D	223.5	166			284
257	Tristan Jarry	PIT	G	249.7	237	249			223
258	Barrett Hayton	UTA	C	148.0	274		205	231
259	William Karlsson	VGK	C	225.0	254	234	238	283	206
260	Yegor Sharangovich	CGY	C,LW,RW	251.3			213
261	Sean Couturier	PHI	C	230.0					215
262	Jake Walman	EDM	D	233.0	213			253
263	Calvin Pickard	EDM	G	256.3	280		188
264	Bobby McMann	TOR	LW	256.7	245	245	231
265	Justin Faulk	STL	D	257.0	223
266	Casey Mittelstadt	BOS	C	237.5			221	258	246
267	Mattias Ekholm	EDM	D	238.0	201			274
268	Brent Burns	COL	D	260.7	224
269	Mikael Backlund	CGY	C	245.0					225
270	Phillip Danault	LAK	C	248.0			225
271	Tyson Foerster	PHI	LW,RW	265.7	253	239		273	217
272	Maxim Shabanov	NYI		199.0	282		200
273	Zack Bolduc	MTL	RW	254.0	268	228		239
274	Evan Rodrigues	FLA	C,LW,RW	254.0			233
275	Olen Zellweger	ANA	D	256.0				234
276	Luke Evangelista	NSH	RW	259.0	264	250			222
277	Jordan Eberle	SEA	RW	259.5	269	238			230
278	Nick Paul	TBL	C,LW	261.0					235
279	Owen Power	BUF	D	223.0				236
280	John Klingberg	SJS	D	224.0	256	231		251
281	Connor Zary	CGY	C,LW,RW	263.5				237
282	Colton Parayko	STL	D	278.3	204			286
283	Stefan Noesen	NJD	LW,RW	234.0					240
284	Trevor Moore	LAK	LW,RW	236.0			241
285	Brandt Clarke	LAK	D	237.0	258	248		238
286	Max Domi	TOR	C,LW	270.0					244
287	Dan Vladar	PHI	G	270.5				246
288	Chandler Stephenson	SEA	C	273.0	284		218	247
289	Danila Yurov	MIN	RW	246.0			248
290	Mavrik Bourque	DAL	C,RW	275.0					249
291	Martin Pospisil	CGY	C,RW	278.0					250
292	Leevi Merilainen	OTT	G	279.7	251
293	Kevin Lankinen	VAN	G	281.0	250			265	239
294	Kyle Palmieri	NYI	RW	264.0	259		244	278	227
295	Jonathan Drouin	NYI	LW,RW	266.0	297			211
296	Yaroslav Askarov	SJS	G	271.0	236			272
297	Fabian Zetterlund	OTT	LW,RW	290.0	262	246
298	Darren Raddysh	TBL	D	280.0	257
299	Sean Durzi	UTA	D	285.0	296		214
300	Dawson Mercer	NJD	C,RW	287.0				259

MORE FACEOFF.IN YOUR INBOX.

CLICK TO SUBSCRIBE TO OUR DAILY NEWSLETTER