Daily Faceoff is a news site with no direct affiliation to the NHL, or NHLPA

Fantasy Hockey Injury Replacements: Who to Add for MacKinnon, Bedard and Makar

Brock Seguin
Nov 18, 2026, 18:00 EST

Fantasy Hockey Injury Replacements: Who to Add for MacKinnon, Bedard and Makar

It’s been a tough week for fantasy hockey superstars. Last Thursday, Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar both got hurt in Colorado’s overtime loss in Ottawa. MacKinnon is expected to be sidelined until at least mid-December, and Makar will miss at least another week. Then Connor Bedard suffered another shoulder injury on Tuesday and is expected to miss significant time.

Replacing them won’t be easy, but you can fill the void with Colorado’s and Chicago’s in-house replacements or look for help elsewhere. Here are your MacKinnon, Bedard and Makar replacements:

Watch:

In-House Replacements for MacKinnon/Bedard

Nazem Kadri (COL – C/LW/RW – 71% Rostered)

With MacKinnon out, not much has changed for Kadri. He’s still on the second line with Jaden Schwartz and T.J. Hughes, as well as PP1. He played 17:21, with an assist, four SOG and 10 shot attempts in the first game without MacKinnon. His shot volume has been incredible lately. He’s had at least three SOG in five straight games and has averaged 3.2 SOG and 6.1 shot attempts over his last 10 games. He’s near a point per game over his last 15, with five goals and nine assists (14 points). Surprisingly, he’s still available in 30% of leagues.

Brock Nelson (COL – C – 60% Rostered)

Nelson got the biggest boost with MacKinnon out. He moved up to the top line with Artturi Lehkonen and Martin Necas but remains on PP2. The promotion came at a good time for Nelson, who has started to heat up after a sluggish start. He had just three goals in his first 13 games but has three in his last eight, including two in his last three. He played 18:49 in the first game without MacKinnon and finished with a goal, three SOG and five shot attempts. Let’s see if that’s a sign of things to come in the expanded role.

Anton Frondell (CHI – C – 23% Rostered)

In the first practice without Bedard, Frondell was promoted to the top line with Roman Kantserov and Tyler Bertuzzi but remained on PP2. Frondell is on a three-game point streak, but his ice time had been dwindling lately. The promotion should get him back to around 17 minutes per game. His shot volume is sporadic, but he has huge spike games, and overall he’s averaging a steady 3.9 shot attempts per game. Let’s see if that improves with more ice time.

Frank Nazar (CHI – C – 15% Rostered)

Nazar will skate on a line with Patrick Kane and Oliver Moore and see PP1 time. He’s playing extremely well. He’s on a three-game goal streak, with five goals during that stretch. Overall, he has 10 goals in his last 16 games, tied for 18th in the NHL over that span. He’s shooting 31.3% in that stretch, so the 50-goal pace isn’t sustainable, but his shot volume has climbed over the last couple of weeks, to 2.5 SOG and 5.1 shot attempts per game over his last eight. If he’s averaging 20 minutes per game with that kind of shot volume, he should perform like at least a 30-goal scorer for the rest of the season.

Other Centre Options

Shane Pinto (OTT – C – 36% Rostered)

Pinto is quietly on pace for 34 goals and 31 assists. I talked about him a couple of weeks ago as a player who is incredibly reliable because he plays massive minutes in Ottawa. He chips in consistently but doesn’t have many spike games. He has 10 points (7G / 3A) in his last 10 games, with usage, shot volume and hit volume that make him one of the most reliable forwards in fantasy. Averaging north of 21 minutes, 4.0 shot attempts and 1.8 hits per game gives him a super sturdy floor, and he’s already shown this season that he has 35-goal, 65-point upside. His value took another bump this week when he was moved to PP1 in Monday’s practice.

Quinton Byfield (LAK – C – 34% Rostered)

I’ve consistently preached patience with Byfield, particularly on our DFO Fantasy Show Live Streams. It still feels like we’re in a holding pattern, but there’s so much to like. He’s scored four goals in his last eight games, so that’s a start. The shot volume has been outstanding: 3.2 SOG and a robust 6.2 shot attempts per game over his last nine games. He’s had at least four SOG in five of those nine games and at least five shot attempts in eight of nine. Getting Kevin Fiala back should keep improving Byfield’s results in the coming weeks.

Pierre-Luc Dubois (WSH – C/LW – 21% Rostered)

Things aren’t going to plan in Washington, with the Capitals hovering around .500, but Dubois has had a nice start to the season. He has 12 points (5G / 7A) in 14 games, including four goals and an assist in his last five. His floor isn’t great because he doesn’t shoot or hit much, but he’s very quietly produced at a 64-point (20G / 44A) pace since joining the Capitals in 2025.

Dawson Mercer (WPG – C/RW – 13% Rostered)

Mercer’s arrival has drastically changed the look of the Jets’ second line. Winnipeg has been short on secondary scoring for a while, but Mercer has given them a shot in the arm, scoring five goals in his last six games. We’ll see how sustainable it is, but he has eight points (5G / 3A) in his last 10 games while averaging 2.0 SOG and 3.4 shot attempts. He’s worth short-term consideration to see if he can keep it rolling, especially as the Jets head into a terrific stretch of the schedule. They have eight games over the next two weeks, giving them one of the best upcoming strengths of schedule.

William Karlsson (VGK – C – 6% Rostered)

I mentioned Karlsson was snakebitten when the Golden Knights were streamers a couple of weeks back, and the puck luck has started to break his way. He has four points (2G / 2A) in his last four games. More importantly, he’s had 13 SOG and 20 shot attempts in his last three games, or 4.3 SOG and 6.7 shot attempts per game. In deeper leagues, that might be worth tapping into, although the Golden Knights have very few light nights coming up. He’s a pickup if you have a clear need at C in the wake of the MacKinnon and Bedard injuries and light nights are irrelevant to you. He’s never been a super high-volume shooter, but he’s averaging 3.8 shot attempts per game this season, and the recent spike is reminiscent of the volume we saw when he randomly scored 43 goals in 2018.

Filip Chytil (VAN – C – 1% Rostered)

Chytil has been getting a ton of airtime from me lately. I mentioned him last week as a weekend streamer on the DFO Fantasy Show, on Monday as a Week 8 streamer and now again today. The intriguing part was his usage and shot volume before he got hurt, and he’s picked up where he left off. He has three goals in three games since returning to the Canucks lineup, averaging 3.3 SOG, 5.7 shot attempts and 17:53 TOI in those games. He’s a deep-league pickup only right now, but if you lost MacKinnon or Bedard and your options are limited, Chytil could be a saving grace.

In-House Replacements for Makar

Devon Toews (COL – D – 85% Rostered)

Toews is the one who replaced Makar on PP1, so he’s worth mentioning. He’s only available in 15% of leagues, but in shallow leagues where he is available, he has 12 points (4G / 8A) in his last 11 games. He’s red hot, and the new role should help him stay that way.

Sam Malinski (COL – D – 24% Rostered)

Malinski was promoted to the top pair with Toews and has played 23:29 and 24:19 since Makar got hurt. If he consistently plays close to 24 minutes a night, he can be a serviceable replacement for Makar. He’s still searching for his first goal of the season, but not for lack of trying: he’s averaging 5.7 shot attempts per game over his last nine games. Let’s not forget that he was a 40-point defenseman last year and is on pace for even more assists this year. Once the puck starts going in, Malinski will be a great add, and there’s no better time than now while he’s eating 24 minutes a night.

Other Defenseman Options

Zayne Parekh (CGY – D – 26% Rostered)

Every time you turn on a Flames game, you see Parekh making things happen. He has seven points (2G / 5A) in his last 13 games, and the shot volume continues to impress at 4.3 shot attempts per game this season. He certainly won’t replace Makar’s plus-minus, but from a real-life perspective, his game is the most similar to Makar’s. That’s mostly meaningless for fantasy at the moment, but man, he could be special. I have very high hopes for Zayne Parekh.

Jamie Drysdale (PHI – D – 19% Rostered)

After going pointless in his first 11 games of the season, Drysdale has 12 points (2G / 10A) in his last 13. The shot and hit volume don’t give him much of a floor, but he’s playing huge minutes on the top pair and the top power-play unit for a Flyers team that has found its offence, scoring three or more goals in 10 of its last 15 games. Since the Flyers’ offence turned the corner, Drysdale has been on a career-best heater.

Sam Rinzel (CHI – D – 17% Rostered)

The Rinzel situation is worth monitoring because Bowen Byram is returning soon and will presumably bump him from PP1. It’s hard to ignore Rinzel’s nine assists, 4.2 shot attempts and 22 minutes per game over his last six games. I fear Byram will eat into some of his value, but no one has a better schedule for the rest of this week than Rinzel, so if you need a short-term D option, he’s it.

Logan Mailloux (STL – D – 4% Rostered)

Mailloux made his season debut last Tuesday and has four points (1G / 3A) in his last two games. He’s playing sizable minutes on the top pair and the second power-play unit. We started to see value from him after the Olympics last season, when he had 10 points (4G / 6A) in his final 23 games. He averaged nearly 23 minutes per game in that stretch and provided a decent floor in banger leagues (1.7 SOG, 1.6 hits and 1.1 blocks per game). All told, he has five goals and nine assists (14 points) in his last 27 games. That’s a 16-goal, 44-point pace over 84 games, and he chips in hits and blocks.

Sam Dickinson (SJS – D – 2% Rostered) / Eric Pohlkamp (SJS – D – 1% Rostered)

Dickinson is more of a speculative add in deep leagues because he’s currently on PP1 in San Jose. That spot has been a revolving door all season, with at least four defensemen getting a turn there and a stretch where the Sharks rolled five forwards. Who knows how long it will last. He hasn’t done anything with it yet, but he’s at least worth monitoring. He did have 29 goals and 91 points in his final OHL season, so he seems like a good fit for the role; he just hasn’t found his offensive game at the NHL level yet.

Pohlkamp might be worth a look for the Sharks as well. The rookie blueliner has a booming shot and scored double-digit goals in all three of his college seasons, so he could come into play if his role keeps growing. He skated on the top pair in Wednesday’s practice and is averaging 4.3 shot attempts per game since being called up. If he ever gets on PP1, he’d be the one to own.

Erik Gustafsson (LAK – D – 1% Rostered)

It’s shocking to see Gustafsson back in fantasy relevance. He was playing for the Grand Rapids Griffins last season because he couldn’t stick on the Red Wings’ blue line. Now he’s playing nearly 23 minutes a night and has replaced Brandt Clarke on PP1 in Los Angeles. He has six points (1G / 5A) and 4.2 shot attempts per game over his last nine games, the stretch where his usage skyrocketed. In deep leagues where you’re desperate, he’ll absolutely be serviceable.