Daily Faceoff is a news site with no direct affiliation to the NHL, or NHLPA

NHL Best Bets, Predictions, Picks, Odds for Tuesday, November 17

Greg Liodice
Nov 17, 2026, 15:22 EST

New York Islanders' Matthew Schaefer and Bo Horvat
Credit: IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Last night was pretty rough for me, losing both of my NHL best bets, but it’s another day to move on and move forward.

Tonight, we have a big slate on the docket, and there are three games that caught my eye. First is the Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders, then we have the Toronto Maple Leafs vs Chicago Blackhawks in the Original Six Series, and finally we cap it off with a late night tussle between the Dallas Stars and Vegas Golden Knights.

So what do you say? Let’s take a look at my NHL best bets for Tuesday, November 17. Don’t forget to follow me on the Action Network app for more picks and analysis!

Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders

The Blue Jackets have been a total disappointment this season. I bet you’ve read that sentence quite often in your time as a hockey fan, right?

Ultimately, the two players who have given any reason to watch this team have been Kent Johnson and Zach Werenski. The rest have not played to the level I was hoping to see, and that includes Adam Fantilli.

Now, the Islanders are somewhat of an anomaly. I think they’ve played a lot better than what I was expecting of them, but I still question their longevity this season.

That likely doesn’t hurt us in the short term, but long term, they are a prime candidate for monitoring their future market to miss the playoffs.

Matthew Schaefer has picked up right where he left off. He’s a total beauty averaging over a point per game as a 19-year-old defenseman. Just crazy. Beyond him, his draftmate Victor Eklund has registered a point in his past five games, forming tremendous chemistry with veteran Brayden Schenn.

Not only that, I think Simon Holmstrom is one of the most underrated players in the league, after registering a hat trick against the Ducks on Saturday.

Ilya Sorokin will take the net for the Isles against Columbus’ Cam Talbot. If you have read my work on Action Network over the past five years, you’ll know how I feel about Talbot. I’m just not a fan.

But credit to him, he’s been playing at a high level, whereas his partner Jet Greaves has not.

Still, I don’t think he’ll be able to stop the Islanders tonight, who have been playing really well.

Pick: Islanders 60 Minute Moneyline (+110, FanDuel)

Toronto Maple Leafs vs Chicago Blackhawks

The Original Six Series continues as the Maple Leafs take on the Blackhawks, and it’s two teams desperate for a restart.

My goodness has Toronto been a disaster, losing eight of its last nine games.

But to its defense, the Leafs have been under fire with injuries all season. Kirill Marchenko, Morgan Rielly, Colton Sissons, Nick Blankenburg, have all missed time, and still haven’t seen Max Domi or Miles Wood this season.

I don’t, however, think that’s a valid excuse.

Because the roster construction seems to be the same kind of construction as it was when the Leafs had Mitch Marner. Very top-heavy, loose goaltending, but a whole lot of goals.

Auston Matthews and William Nylander are self-explanatory. They’re all-world players, and the addition of Gavin McKenna will be huge for this franchise long term. But Jack Roslovic is Toronto’s third-leading goal scorer – and its big free agent signing Darren Raddysh, is a -12.

The Blackhawks are just the total opposite. They don’t play great hockey, but I don’t think many expected them to. This is another team that has far too many holes in it.

Sure, you have Connor Bedard, but who else? Patrick Kane is past his prime. Frank Nazar is nice, but inconsistent. I do like Roman Kantserov, but can he keep it up? He had a point in nine straight games before going point-less to the Jets on Friday.

Needless to say, I don’t feel great about goaltending on either side. Spencer Knight has definitely struggled with his .882 SV% and -2.3 GSAx, while tonight Sergei Bobrovsky gets the nod.

Bob has been pretty brutal during his first season with the Leafs, playing to an .882 SV% and a -2.3 GSAx – like Knight.

This is not a game for defenses. Both rank in the bottom-10 in expected goals against. Pair that with brutal goaltending, and you have a solid recipe for the over.

Pick: Over 6.5 (-108, DraftKings)

Dallas Stars vs Vegas Golden Knights

Nothing like a Western Conference powerhouse battle.

Anytime the Stars and the Knights go at it, it’s usually must-see TV. Vegas is currently third place in the West, with the Stars, who have won three out of their last four, are just a mere three points back.

Dallas will still be without both Miro Heiskanen and Lian Bischel, which affects its blueline greatly, with Trey Taylor and Kyle Burroughs stepping in relief.

Vegas, on the other hand, was a major disappointment on Sunday, after losing to the Canucks at home by the score of 6-3. It was the Knights’ second loss in a row, and Vancouver has been abhorrent all season, which is immediately a red flag.

The Knights’ offense has been tremendous in the past 10 games, but defensively, have definitely slowed down, playing to a 41.55 xGA – which is 22nd in the league.

Meanwhile, in that stretch, the Stars have played polar opposite hockey, ranking third in expected goals against, while playing to a sixth-worst xGF%. However, the losses of Bischel and Heiskanen hurt Dallas’s defensive ceiling and it may be an opportune time for Vegas to pounce.

I think this game is going to be pretty close, but ultimately see Vegas pulling out the win.

Pick: Vegas Golden Knights ML (-132, FanDuel)