Who are the top-graded teams at the quarter-season mark?

The 2026-27 NHL season is just about 25 percent of the way complete, meaning it’s a great time to take stock of the standings and see which teams are exceeding, meeting, or wildly underperforming their preseason expectations.
Of all 32 teams in the league there are two teams that have clearly dominated their starts to the season above the rest, one in each conference.
In the East, the reigning Stanley Cup champion Carolina Hurricanes look every bit the part of a team that can become the fourth team to pull off a repeat in the past 12 years, while in the West, the Minnesota Wild have jumped out to a sizable lead in a Central Division that was an absolute dog fight at the top throughout the 2025-26 campaign.
On Tuesday’s episode of Daily Faceoff LIVE, host Tyler Yaremchuk and co-host and former NHL goaltender Carter Hutton discussed why the Hurricanes and Wild are the two teams most deserving of A-grades on their quarter-pole report cards.
Tyler Yaremchuk: Let’s give out our first letter, Hutts, it is obviously an A. You start at the top. When you look around the NHL, what team are you most comfortable with giving an A-grade to?
Carter Hutton: I didn’t want to get too creative here, it’s really hard… I went with the Carolina Hurricanes. I just think after their Cup run, it’s been pretty impressive what they’ve been able to do with injuries to Jordan Staal, with Freddie Andersen being gone. Kochetkov coming in and playing so well. And then their depth scoring, at plus-40 in their goal differential is a big, strong case to show you how good this team can be. Post-Stanley Cup is the most important. This team played a lot of hard hockey down the stretch, and for me it’s their depth showing up. I think this global trip that they just went on, seeing them sweep Seattle and what they did over there, the likes of Jankowski finding the back of the net… Jackson Blake, he’s got a point streak going to 11 games. It’s kind of these guys that are winning by committee, and that’s what’s so impressive to me. There wasn’t this Stanley Cup hangover, they’re able to just pair it right with winning again, and a demanding coach that wants this from you consistently all the time, so I’m giving it to the Carolina Hurricanes, Tyler.
Tyler Yaremchuk: Yeah, I don’t disagree with them at all getting an A because they’re the number one team in the NHL on points percentage… There probably was an option to give it to the Oilers. We’ve talked a lot of Oilers, I wanted to go somewhere else. I think what the Minnesota Wild have done in that tough, tough Central Division has been super impressive. Only three regulation losses this year, that’s tied for the fewest in the NHL. I don’t think you could write a better script outside of maybe having Quinn Hughes extended, but the other thing that’s really encouraging with Minnesota, Jesper Wallstedt looks like he’s ready to be one of the best goalies in the NHL, Hutts.
You can watch the full segment and the rest of the episode below…